Scan barcode
nthingrid's review against another edition
informative
reflective
medium-paced
5.0
What a rich and wholesome set of books. I have always loved extended family sagas based in historic events, but this seemed to touch on all themes in which I have particular interest: class, poverty, culture (i.e. clash and absorption of western vs eastern), honor and duty, gender roles and norms, aging and the change of abilities over a lifetime, revolution and the constant struggle for freedom/progress (freedom vs progress, perhaps?), etc.
And on top of all this as the main theme is the fundamental human connection to the earth for both life and death. Buck kneads and stretches the human experience over a vast frame but never lets us forget our roots and humanity. Her characters learn and if her readers are careful, they too can absorb the wisdom of multiple generations and find patterns in context. And her prose is the final unique touch, with a simplicity and plainness difficult to find elsewhere.
All three books get 5* from me.
And on top of all this as the main theme is the fundamental human connection to the earth for both life and death. Buck kneads and stretches the human experience over a vast frame but never lets us forget our roots and humanity. Her characters learn and if her readers are careful, they too can absorb the wisdom of multiple generations and find patterns in context. And her prose is the final unique touch, with a simplicity and plainness difficult to find elsewhere.
All three books get 5* from me.
sharon_huestis's review against another edition
3.0
The narrative style evolves over the course of the three books. The first is a morality tale, the second seems merely to set the stage for the third, and the third seems forced to complete the cycle. I would only recommend the first.
haciesielski's review against another edition
2.0
I got through the first book, but it just didn't hold my interest to want to read the other 2
dblakeney's review against another edition
emotional
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
4.75
alliecat_'s review against another edition
5.0
excellent - it took me a month to read this but I found it extremely interesting and indeed even modern to read. It doesnt really read like a book written in 1933. I loved it, can recommend
ashvaberle16's review against another edition
2.0
Loved the first book, the second book was meh and I couldn't even get through the third one.