waywardsin's review

Go to review page

hopeful informative inspiring reflective fast-paced

4.25

gmpoliseno's review

Go to review page

5.0

Very important read. Well researched and compassionately written

the_magpie_reader's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I absolutely loved the thoughtfulness and deep respect (both for the Scriptures and for the people who have been hurt by the improper use of the same Scriptures) that went into writing this book.
I wish it had been translated in a few languages other than English, so that I could share it with more people!

bethpeninger's review

Go to review page

5.0

Last month I read another book of the same topic but with a differing view. I couldn't get both books read in one month so I continued the exploration of this controversial topic this month. For my thoughts on last month's read of this same topic search for Same-Sex Marriage by Sean McDowell and John Stonestreet.

While Vines doesn't make any claims that his book is a thoughtful approach to same-sex relationships, it is. He presents his views without vitriol, with respect, and with a sincere desire to live within the truth of God's word. Vines is part of a group of Christians who truly and honestly love God and are also gay. He is committed to God's design of sex for marriage so until he marries he remains celibate. You may have winced when you read that statement just now, the one about him marrying. That wince is one of the many reasons Vines wrote this book studying the Bible's take on same-sex relationships.
What is very clear to me after the book I read last month and now this one is that when people are behaving kindly and with level heads, this is definitely an issue of perspective and how scripture is interpreted. As the Church has seen with other topics of debate, people hold different perspectives and interpretations of God's word.
Here's the thing I want to say first. There is zero doubt in my mind that Matthew Vines loves God deeply and is most interested in following the words of God. So he and I get along, so to speak, because those are also my inclinations.
Matthew dives into the history of sex, both opposite and same, in the ancient times. He then applies that history to the biblical texts that Christians who are against same-sex relationships use for their argument. He also studies, as did the book I read last month, the basis of biblical marriage. His study of marriage differed in very significant ways than the definition offered by the authors of last month's book. I'm inclined to lean more into Vines more complete definition rather than the rather limited one offered in Same-Sex Marriage.
Vines makes compelling arguments, using the Bible as his foundation for those arguments. I became especially thoughtful while reading chapter 3, The Gift of Celibacy. His research on when certain scripture passages started to be translated as sexual orientation rather than sexual behavior was very interesting as well. As with the other book, lest you take anything I say in this review out of context I would encourage you to read the book for yourself. It is disheartening that the Church at large has treated people who have same-sex preferences as less than human. As Vines states early on in his book, "This debate is not simply about beliefs and rights; it's about people who are created in God's image." Unfortunately the Church as a whole seems to have forgotten that or have redefined the "qualifications" for who is in the image of God. The image of God is not defined in gender or sexual orientation terms but in characteristics and qualities. Therefore, all humans carry the image of God in them, regardless of sexual orientation.
This is such a complicated and hurtful topic that has been debated and misunderstood. Deep wounds now exist in many people because of the thoughtless actions and words of people who think they need to take up defending God and his word. Newsflash: God doesn't need our help, he can take of himself just fine, better than any of us ever could. Both the authors of last month's book and Vines prove that we can have a thoughtful, respectful, God-honoring conversation about topics of debate - we just have to be willing to be thoughtful, respectful, and God-honoring.
I highly recommend this book, Vines does an excellent job of researching and communicating his interpretation of scripture in regards to same-sex relationships.

kedixon's review

Go to review page

5.0

Mandatory reading

bearbo's review

Go to review page

5.0

Very well researched and thought provoking stuff.
The authors insight on the topic (not only from personal experience) is tremendous.
Def a book anyone studying theology should consider giving a go.

schmann's review

Go to review page

4.0

There were a few minor things toward the end that I didn't quite align with but in general this book summarizes what I understand about scripture. It digs deep into the history and context of the Bible to flip the table on assumptions, misinterpretations, and things that are erroneously preached from pulpits. I highly recommend this book though it will challenge you if you are a non affirming Christian.

quincysmom's review

Go to review page

5.0

Well-researched and very compelling. Can we get a copy of this to mike pence?

hilltroy99's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional informative inspiring reflective medium-paced

3.5

This is a great book if you're still evangelical. The audience outside of that is pretty minimal, unless you're trying to convince an evangelical friend to accept gay people without destroying their faith. The arguments the book makes are solid overall, even if there is a certain amount of dancing-around certain obvious readings. It seems to ignore a couple of obvious things about ancient times, namely that women were seen as property and that marriages were business deals as much as "partnerships" or "covenant relationships," etc. But that kind of comes with the territory of evangelicalism. In all, I think this book was solid even though I don't agree fully with its start point (I don't think the bible is inerrant, etc.), but this was a solid read and if nothing else should increase awareness and empathy for a marginalized group within the biggest group in America.

autumnzana's review

Go to review page

4.0

An important book.