Reviews

The Seventh Child by Erik Valeur

rowingrabbit's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

3.5 stars

If you browse through reviews for this novel, you'll see they run the gamut. I think it's because this is a polarizing book, not popular fiction for the masses. It will appeal to fans of slow, introspective & thoughtful reads. And you'll have to be someone who enjoys a tome you can tuck into. At over 700 pages, this is not a beach book.
Set in Copenhagen, it chronicles the lives of 7 children from their births to middle age. They ended up in an orphanage within days of being born in 1961 & were all adopted except one.
The story begins with a flashback to Sept. 11, 2001. A woman is found dead on the shore of the sound by the orphanage. Police are not sure what to think....accidental death or murder? She has no ID & is surrounded by a weird assortment of objects: a noose, a book, a tree branch & a dead canary. But within hours she's relegated to the back burner as the Twin Towers fall & the world's attention turns to terrorism.
Kongslund has always been an impressive property in an affluent area of the city & was ruled for 60 years by a formidable matron, Magna Ladegaard. In the present day, the orphanage & the city are preparing for a big anniversary party in her honour. It has long been supported by the Danish government & held up as a shining example of family values & all it stands for.
That's why when a mysterious letter begins circulating, alluding to a scandal at Kongslund in 1961, it shakes up not only the staff but the most powerful men in office.
What if not all the babies came from unwed mothers or families in dire circumstances? What if the powerful and/or famous used the orphanage as a dumping ground for pregnancies resulting from illicit or improper affairs?
Magna was known for her strict rules of adoption. The mother never saw the baby & no identifying information was given to the new parents. If the child required medical attention, they got the best to ensure optimal health. But in 1961, one of the 7 babies seemed beyond repair.
They called her Marie. In the subsequent media frenzy, staff described finding the little girl on the doorstep & she became famous as the Kongslund foundling. But Marie's lack of history was the least of her problems. She was severely deformed with misshapen digits, a twisted spine & asymmetrical face. So Magna decided Marie would be her project & adopted her. By 2008, Magna has retired & moved out but Marie never left.
Now in her 40's, Marie is the main protagonist & much of the story is told in her voice, She introduces the reader to each of the characters. The rest of the cast includes the other 6 children, their adoptive families, orphanage staff & 3 men in government: the current (dying) prime minister, the Minister of National Affairs (& next PM) & a sinister former cop who is now head of security for the ministry.
Each character then has a large section in the book detailing their last 40 years. Slowly, we become aware just how intertwined their lives have always been, even if they had no idea. The 7 all crossed paths over the years, unaware they once shared a nursery. Some didn't even know they were adopted until they each received a copy of the letter in 2008. It contained the names of a woman & the child she gave up in 1961. For some reason, this causes a massive but covert investigation by the security chief on behalf of the ministers. But which one of the seven is the child in the letter? All given names were immediately changed once they arrived in Kongslund & original documents destroyed. More importantly, why is the letter stirring up so much fear & urgency?
This is a book that grabbed my attention right away. The main plot line reeks of mystery & secrets and there is a slowly mounting sense of dread from the start. However, I found the middle section bogged down as we are told the history of each person. I understand the need to flesh out the characters so we understand how events shaped them but some editing would have helped move things along & maintain the feeling of suspense. At the end of almost every chapter there is a sentence hinting at something dramatic right around the corner but it lost its' effect after awhile.
But I really wanted to know who the seventh child was & the identity of their parents as this is obviously the crux of the entire plot. After another 200 pages or so, the pace picked up & the last quarter was a page turner as all was revealed with some clever twists & startling revelations.
None of these people are easy to like & almost all have done terrible things. There were also a couple I really detested & I'm happy to say they got what they deserved.There is also a mystical element that flows through the whole book & almost all of the 7 main characters are prone to talking to the dead. It's not clear whether some of the relationships were real or imagined.
This is not a book you want to put down for too long. The large cast & frequent shifts in time frame are difficult to follow at times & you have to pay attention. It's a story that encompasses the themes of childhood, family, politics, xenophobia & hypocrisy. It's incredibly complex & I can't begin to imagine how long it took the author to conceive of all the threads & weave them together.
There are many moments that are sad, poignant & desperate but ultimately, it's about hope & deciding your own fate rather than accepting the hand you you're dealt.

lcmilewski's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This is really a 2.5 star review, but it gets 3 for being incredibly ambitious and unlike any book I've read in recent memory.

This book was long, but I'm not sure why people focused on that so much in their reviews. I love long, detailed epics, so the length and number of characters weren't problems for me; neither was the somewhat confusing naming for those of us who are not Danish. When you're reading a translated book, you need to expect some cultural differences, including challenging names.

The characters were fascinating, awful people, who made this book feel like a slow-motion car crash I couldn't look away from. I was drawn into the first half of the book by the murder teaser at the beginning and the promise of a broad government conspiracy. I also loved the view into Danish culture and modern, post-war history. However, as the background stories got weirder and the mystery petered out rather than exploded, I lost interest and took a lot longer to finish the second half. There was a lot of promise here, but when I could figure out the main twist hundreds of pages in advance, it was hard to muster enthusiasm. To have the ending chapter be virtually incomprehensible after such a drawn-out conclusion was beyond disappointing. Did anybody understand this??

I also found it incredibly strange that the author's premise seems to be that all adopted children never feel like they belong anywhere and are inherently damaged, unable to have typical relationships. This seems like an old-fashioned trope, and hasn't been my experience at all from knowing many people who were adopted, including several in my own family.

saragalisteo's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

Aburrido a más no poder, se hace eterno. La sinopsis parecía interesante pero empieza a flojear desde el principio y no mejora. Mejor ahorraos el tiempo y leed algo que merezca la pena.

labeet's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Uh altså, først var jeg ellevild - sådan ca. de første 150 sider. Men så må jeg sige, at min begejstring kølnedes betragteligt. Gentagelse på gentagelse, helt unødvendige bi-historier, udpenslet politisk indhold, så man til sidst næsten helt havde tabt interessen for indholdet. Ak og ve. Jeg tror sjældent, at jeg er faldet i søvn til en skønlitterær bog så mange gange! Jeg fik dog læst den færdig og fik bekræftet min mistanke om gerningsmand og løsning på bogens gåde. Hvordan i himlens navn har den bog vundet alle de priser?

ap2007's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I'm not sure how I feel about the ending, but overall I enjoyed this. It definitely wasn't a quick read and I did take a couple weeks off here and there, but that's more a reflection on me than the book. However, if you don't enjoy side stories and a bit of meandering, this book is not for you.

booknut7159's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

The story itself was enjoyable, but the book could have benefited from a good editing out of 150 pages. It was a long and winding story.

leenleest89's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

Started to read, but stopped mid 300 pages.

hpnyknits's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

its a long book, and some parts of the book dragged on, but for the most part it was interesting and the mystery surprising. the social and psychological background added to the story.

scrapbookbug's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

tried to get through it.
didn't like the characters, any of them.
found I didn't even care how it ended....

lise_wejlby's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Var i tvivl om jeg skulle læse færdig omkring s. 100. Plottet havde jeg i store træk regnet ud. OK bog, men ikke fantastisk