I like the plot and as the way the story is progressing. but there are still things which are not that developed for me to like it. like how did Kyle know where Caitlin was or Sam ? and other think when its told you can come back to present when you go back to past then how come Kyle kept thinking that. Maybe if it was more explained and Catlin wasn't showed as stupid character I would have loved this book and given 5 stars. The first book I liked her but not now.