An unusual take on a whodunit story, told through the voices of the three women who were closest to New York Supreme Court Judge Joseph Crater, who really disappeared in the 1930s. The author is genius in the way that she weaves the narration and time line between the three women and comes up with what I felt was a very plausible explanation to this unsolved crime. It was so well written that I was shocked to realize that it was based on an actual event. Two thumbs up from this reader!