First of all, this was an audio book for me and I love audio book just as much as books I can read and touch. I was like most kids who loved my mom or dad to read to me. For me, audio books bring this memory back. This book was interesting and the sadness of losing a friend I felt with John. The narration for me was a bit hard to follow. It was not changing in pitch much from one character to another and I like that when I am read a story. It makes it more fun to listen to. "This book was given to me for free at my request and I provided this voluntary review."