Take a photo of a barcode or cover
brenticus's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
lighthearted
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.0
This was... okay-ish. The fairy tale feeling comes and goes in odd ways, and it usually feels strongest when the characters feel most like odd caricatures. The plot just kind of happens, and at some point I stopped trying to care about the sudden twists and turns. They're just there.
There isn't any real satisfaction throughout. Every time the good guys overcome a challenge it feels underwhelming, and every time they don't it feels like they didn't have a chance anyways.
It's just generally a bit of a mess. I think the main characters are fun to read about... but only when the plot isn't trying to progress. That's when it gets weird.
Oh, and also check the content warnings. This book earned some out of the blue.
There isn't any real satisfaction throughout. Every time the good guys overcome a challenge it feels underwhelming, and every time they don't it feels like they didn't have a chance anyways.
It's just generally a bit of a mess. I think the main characters are fun to read about... but only when the plot isn't trying to progress. That's when it gets weird.
Oh, and also check the content warnings. This book earned some out of the blue.
Graphic: Child death and Kidnapping
little_raven's review
3.0

Interesante novela ligera, con notable influencia de los cuentos folklóricos medievales, como se podría imaginar con tan sólo ver el título.
Más que de la princesa (que por cierto, ES pequeña: tiene tan solo 7 años), la historia corre por cuenta de sus dos protectores: un dragón y un caballero de mediana edad. Tal vez no sea la combinación con la que estemos más familiarizados, pero funciona. En lo personal el caballero (Gideon Thorn) ha sido mi favorito, dadas las ínfulas de sofisticación con las que cuenta el dragón (Spike). Sin embargo, como bien dije, la química de la dupla es impecable, tanto en las escenas de acción como en las de humor en las que participan ambos.
Otro punto alto son los villanos. Son horribles y no tienen escrúpulos en hacer lo que sea, pero a fin de cuentas hay una razón para que lo hagan, aunque la manera en la que se explayan sobre el tema pueda ser algo superficial. De nuevo, tal vez los crímenes que cometen sean algo fuertes, por lo que no recomendaría este títulos a niños pequeños o personas de sensibilidad extrema.
Lo que me lleva a una de las críticas, que son ciertas escenas en tono de picaresca que me parecieron totalmente innecesarias y fuera de lugar. No me voy a extender en esto (quien lo lea, sabrá a lo que me refiero), aunque a su favor debo decir que solo se dieron en un par de oportunidades y casi no van en detrimento de la historia en general.
Salvo ese par de inconsistencias, me ha parecido un libro bastante entretenido. Recomendado tanto para los lectores de fantasía medieval como a los de literatura japonesa contemporánea.
absentminded_reader's review
3.0
This is a story about redemption, clothed in a fairytale. Visually, it is a stunning read. There are many passages in this story that I wish to see animated on screen. I loved the lore and the world building. There was care taken with the finer details of the Black Forest, and the guardians of the little princess, the Black Night and the Dragon, were wonderful characters.
Unfortunately, the story seems to have craftsmanship errors. The first problem I had with the story was that it was unclear who the main character was. The story began in the first person point of view of the princess, but soon it became evident that she was mostly a passenger in this tale. The point of view often fluctuated between Gideon's first person point of view and a third person narrative about Gideon. At one point, a passage was related about Gideon in the third person, switched to the 3rd person POV of the villain, then became Gideon's first person POV. The overall affect was jarring. There were also passages that began in the princess's first person POV, then became a third person POV by the next paragraph, complete with adult language, unless seven-year-olds use words like "coalesce" in this fairy world. In fact, one might be confused that this is a children's tale because of the first chapter told from the point of view of a seven year-old, but soon salty language, sexual innuendo, and graphic violence reveal this story to be geared towards young adults.
The narrative also fluctuated between fluffy sections with anime comedy dialogue to thoughtful passages with depth and pathos to nightmarish scenes of grisly horror. There was a decided lack of narrative continuity throughout the entire book. At first, I thought perhaps these were translation errors, but I ended up feeling that this was a problem with the source material. I appreciated the afterword where the author explained his reasoning behind pitting the middle-aged black knight versus the middle-age tyrant. Unfortunately, the tyrant came across as a pointless character, lacking any depth whatsoever. There was an effort to explain his delusions, as well as an effort to reveal who the real villain of the story was, but I found the true villain wanting in depth as well.
So, it was a terrible book? No. It was a lovely tale. Despite the narrative flaws, and the flat villains, the story was rich, and the main characters were interesting. I felt compelled to continue reading. Isn't that what we want from a book?
This was Tsubaki Tokino's first work, and although it is rough in places, his visionary talent shines brightly. I loved the ideas presented as well as the Japanese take on European fairytales. The gruesome monster at the end was also chilling and vividly described. Often, I find the epilogue anticlimactic, but this epilogue hit all the right notes, including a heart-breaking scene were the reader found closure along with the main characters for the most horrific event in the story. I look forward to Tokino's future stories. Fans of anime fantasy should feel right at home here.
Unfortunately, the story seems to have craftsmanship errors. The first problem I had with the story was that it was unclear who the main character was. The story began in the first person point of view of the princess, but soon it became evident that she was mostly a passenger in this tale. The point of view often fluctuated between Gideon's first person point of view and a third person narrative about Gideon. At one point, a passage was related about Gideon in the third person, switched to the 3rd person POV of the villain, then became Gideon's first person POV. The overall affect was jarring. There were also passages that began in the princess's first person POV, then became a third person POV by the next paragraph, complete with adult language, unless seven-year-olds use words like "coalesce" in this fairy world. In fact, one might be confused that this is a children's tale because of the first chapter told from the point of view of a seven year-old, but soon salty language, sexual innuendo, and graphic violence reveal this story to be geared towards young adults.
The narrative also fluctuated between fluffy sections with anime comedy dialogue to thoughtful passages with depth and pathos to nightmarish scenes of grisly horror. There was a decided lack of narrative continuity throughout the entire book. At first, I thought perhaps these were translation errors, but I ended up feeling that this was a problem with the source material. I appreciated the afterword where the author explained his reasoning behind pitting the middle-aged black knight versus the middle-age tyrant. Unfortunately, the tyrant came across as a pointless character, lacking any depth whatsoever. There was an effort to explain his delusions, as well as an effort to reveal who the real villain of the story was, but I found the true villain wanting in depth as well.
So, it was a terrible book? No. It was a lovely tale. Despite the narrative flaws, and the flat villains, the story was rich, and the main characters were interesting. I felt compelled to continue reading. Isn't that what we want from a book?
This was Tsubaki Tokino's first work, and although it is rough in places, his visionary talent shines brightly. I loved the ideas presented as well as the Japanese take on European fairytales. The gruesome monster at the end was also chilling and vividly described. Often, I find the epilogue anticlimactic, but this epilogue hit all the right notes, including a heart-breaking scene were the reader found closure along with the main characters for the most horrific event in the story. I look forward to Tokino's future stories. Fans of anime fantasy should feel right at home here.